Five Starter Scenarios for First-Time Keepers

Keepers, forge ahead! And players, for once you can read along too. There are no spoilers here, just what each scenario is and why I’d reach for it.

A friend of mine is about to run Call of Cthulhu as Keeper for the first time and asked me where to start. I put together a list, and then I realized I’ve had this same conversation with a lot of new Keepers. So here it is for anyone else about to sit behind the screen for the first time.

What I look for in a first scenario is simple. It shouldn’t need much context to get going, and it should fit in a single session of about three hours with good time management.

1. The Haunting (Chaosium)

Free in the 7th edition Quick-Start Rules: Call of Cthulhu Quick-Start Rules

It’s the classic first scenario. Almost everyone started here, so your players get the same war stories as every other Call of Cthulhu player.

Confession: I don’t tend to start people with this one. The burn is a little slower than I’d like, so I usually make changes to the hook and streamline it.

2. The Necropolis (Chaosium)

In Gateways to Terror, a book of three one-hour starter scenarios with pregens. $9.99 PDF, or $19.99 print with the PDF included: Gateways to Terror

The most dungeon-like of the five, so it’s a good bridge for D&D players, but it runs on suspense and investigation. Good for delving and desperation.

3. Transatlantic Terror (Goodman Games)

Full title Age of Cthulhu: Transatlantic Terror. It’s no longer for sale as far as I can tell, so you may have to hunt for a copy.

Set on a 1920s ocean liner, so nobody can just leave. Great period feel, and the threat comes from a part of the Mythos that isn’t Lovecraft’s. It needs modest updating to work with the 7th edition rules.

4. The Mummy of Pemberley Grange (Type40)

On DriveThruRPG in Chaosium’s Miskatonic Repository: The Mummy of Pemberley Grange

A tightly bounded country-house scenario built for one session, with maps, handouts and pregens. Real tension, a genuine chance of sudden death, and a steady sense of dread.

5. Murder in the Footlights (Chaosium)

Free from Chaosium as a PDF: Murder in the Footlights

This one is written for Basic Roleplaying (BRP), not Call of Cthulhu, but the two games share the same engine, so it can be reskinned to Call of Cthulhu. It’s set in a vaudeville theater in 1936 Boston, for two to four investigators, and it already uses Sanity. There are no pregens, so plan on making characters or bringing your own.

Or start with one of mine

If I were going to start people out with one of my own, it would have to be one of these three. They don’t need much context to get going, and they can be run in three hours with good time management.

  • Blank: Boston, New Year’s Eve, as the clock counts down to 1925. Burlesque, comedy and hot jazz, plus a band that needs help.
  • Collection: a strange problem at the Orne Library of Miskatonic University in 1924. Two pages, theater of the mind.
  • Dissonance: London in the first week of a new national radio service, and a backstage tour.

All of my scenarios for sale are listed here: Adventures for Sale

I’ve run all of the above at the comic shop for first-timers except The Necropolis.

Good luck, new Keepers, and less luck to your players!